Game Vault Forum
Verified Gaming Journal • Google Publisher ca-pub-6121667798720008
Tips

How to Choose the Right Video Game for You: A Simple Guide to Finding Your Next Game

Overwhelmed by massive backlogs and endless game stores? Instead of asking what is the best game, ask what experience you want right now. A practical guide to discovering your next favorite title.

Elena Rostova
Community Specialist • Sept 8, 2026 • 11 min read
How to Choose the Right Video Game for You: A Simple Guide to Finding Your Next Game

Sometimes the hardest gaming decision isn't beating a difficult boss, reaching the next rank, or choosing the right weapon. It's deciding what to play in the first place.

You open your game library and see dozens of titles. You scroll through a digital store and find hundreds more. Friends recommend their favourites. You watch a few trailers, read some reviews, save a couple of games to your wishlist, and somehow end up playing the same game you've already played for the last three weeks.

The problem usually isn't a lack of games. There are simply too many choices.

A game can be highly rated and still be completely wrong for you. You might buy a critically praised open-world adventure only to realize that you don't enjoy spending hours exploring a huge map. Someone else might recommend a competitive multiplayer game because they love the intensity, while you would rather play something at your own pace. Even two games from the same genre can feel completely different once you actually start playing them.

That's why choosing the right video game shouldn't begin with asking, "What's the best game?"

A better question is: "What kind of gaming experience do I actually want right now?"

That small change can make finding your next game much easier. Whether you're a longtime gamer with a huge backlog or someone who doesn't know what to play next, the goal isn't to discover the game that everyone else loves. It's to find something that fits you.

Start With the Experience You Want

Before looking at genres, ratings, or recommendations, think about what you want from your next gaming session:

  • Are you looking for something relaxing after a long day?
  • Maybe you want something competitive that gives you a reason to improve.
  • Perhaps you want a strong story and memorable characters.
  • Or maybe you don't care about the story at all and just want satisfying gameplay.

These differences are important because people often choose games based on their reputation rather than the experience they actually want. For example, someone might say, "I want a good game," when what they really mean is, "I want something I can play for 30 minutes without having to remember a complicated story." Those are very different requirements.

Before searching for video game recommendations, try describing the experience you're looking for in a few words:

  • Relaxing or Casual
  • Competitive or Challenging
  • Story-driven or Immersive
  • Strategic or Creative
  • Fast-paced or Deliberate
  • Short and focused vs. Long-term

You don't have to choose only one. You might want a strategic game that is also relaxing, or a competitive game that you can play casually without taking it too seriously. Once you know what you're looking for, the enormous list of possible games becomes much smaller.

Think About the Genres You Actually Enjoy

Understanding video game genres can help, but don't treat genre labels as strict rules. Action, RPG, strategy, simulation, racing, sports, adventure, horror, shooter, fighting, and puzzle games can all provide very different experiences.

Even within one genre, the differences can be huge. Two RPGs might both feature character progression, but one could focus heavily on exploration and storytelling while another is built around combat and character customization.

The same thing happens with strategy games. Some require careful planning over long periods, while others demand quick decisions during active battles.

So when choosing a video game genre, don't just ask: "What genre do I like?"

Ask: "What parts of that genre do I enjoy?"

  • Maybe you like racing games but don't care about realistic simulation.
  • Maybe you enjoy shooters but prefer slower tactical gameplay over constant running and shooting.
  • Maybe you like sports games but mainly enjoy building teams rather than playing individual matches.

Those details are far more useful when you're trying to find a game you'll actually enjoy.

Use Games You Already Love as Clues

One of the best ways to discover new video games is to look backward before looking forward.

Think about three games you genuinely enjoyed. Now ask yourself what they had in common:

  • Was it the combat?
  • The exploration?
  • The competitive element?
  • The freedom to make choices?
  • The progression system?
  • The atmosphere?
  • The multiplayer experience?
  • The ability to play for a short time without committing to a huge campaign?

This approach is much more useful than simply searching for "best games." For example, imagine you enjoy a particular strategy game because you like planning several moves ahead. You might discover that the thing you enjoy isn't the game's setting at all; it's the decision-making.

That opens the door to other games that provide similar strategic experiences, even if they're completely different in appearance. Don't copy the title. Copy the reason you liked it.

Consider How Much Time You Actually Have

This is one of the most overlooked parts of choosing a game. A game might be excellent but completely unsuitable for your current schedule.

If you regularly have only 30 minutes to play, a game that requires long uninterrupted sessions may become frustrating. You may constantly feel like you're stopping just as you're getting into it. On the other hand, if you have several hours available on weekends, a short game might leave you wanting more.

Think about your normal gaming time:

  • If you have limited time: Look for games that let you make meaningful progress in relatively short sessions.
  • If you have several hours: You might enjoy larger adventures, simulations, RPGs, or games with deeper progression systems.
  • If your schedule changes: A game with flexible session lengths may be the better choice.

This is why choosing a game based on your available time is just as important as considering genre. The "best" game for you isn't necessarily the biggest game; it's the one that fits your life.

Decide How Much Challenge You Want

Challenge is another personal preference that people sometimes overlook.

Some gamers want a game that constantly pushes them. Losing is part of the fun because every mistake provides something to learn. Others play specifically to relax and don't want every session to feel like an examination.

Neither approach is wrong. The important thing is knowing where you sit.

If you're already mentally tired, a brutally difficult game might not be what you need. But if you've been playing casual games for weeks and you're beginning to feel bored, a more demanding experience could be exactly what you're looking for.

There's also a middle ground: some games allow you to adjust difficulty, change play styles, or approach challenges at your own pace. Those can be useful when you're not sure exactly how much pressure you want.

Think About Whether You Want Competition

Competitive gaming can be incredibly engaging, but it isn't for everyone.

Some players enjoy rankings, leaderboards, matches against human opponents, and the feeling of gradually becoming better. Others would rather compete against the game itself.

If competition motivates you, multiplayer shooters, sports games, fighting games, racing games, and strategy titles may provide the kind of experience you're looking for. But if losing to other players tends to ruin your mood, a highly competitive game may not be the best choice for a relaxing evening.

There's nothing wrong with recognizing that. A game should fit your personality rather than forcing you to enjoy a style of play you don't actually like.

Consider Single-Player, Multiplayer or Something in Between

Another useful question is whether you want to play alone or with other people.

Single-player games can offer a more controlled experience. You can often stop when you want, explore at your own pace, and focus on the story or gameplay without worrying about teammates.

Multiplayer games offer something different: they can be social, unpredictable, and highly replayable. Playing with friends can also turn a familiar game into a completely different experience.

Then there are games that offer both. You might enjoy a game alone most of the time but occasionally want to play with friends. When choosing your next game, think about what your social energy looks like too. There are days when interacting with other players sounds great, and days when the last thing you want is another person shouting through a headset.

Don't Ignore the Story

For some gamers, gameplay is everything. For others, the story is the reason they play.

If you're someone who becomes attached to characters and wants to know what happens next, a story-heavy game may hold your attention much longer than a mechanically excellent game with little narrative.

Ask yourself what keeps you playing:

  • If you regularly find yourself skipping dialogue and cutscenes, you probably shouldn't choose your next game primarily because people praise its story.
  • On the other hand, if characters, world-building, and narrative decisions are what you remember most about your favourite games, prioritize those features.

Knowing your own gaming preferences makes the search much easier.

Pay Attention to the Game's Pace

Pacing can make or break your experience.

Some games are constantly moving. There is always something happening, and the game expects you to react quickly. Others take their time: you might spend several minutes exploring, managing equipment, reading information, building something, or planning your next move.

Neither style is inherently better. It's about what your brain enjoys. If you like immediate action, a slow game may feel boring. If you enjoy thinking, exploring, and taking your time, a relentlessly fast game may become exhausting.

You need to know what kind of rhythm you enjoy.

Use Reviews, But Don't Let Them Make the Decision for You

Reviews are useful, but they should be treated as information rather than instructions. A reviewer can tell you what they liked, what they disliked, and what type of player might enjoy the game. But they can't completely predict whether you'll enjoy it.

A game receiving a 9/10 doesn't mean you'll have a 9/10 experience. Instead of looking only at the score, pay attention to the reasons behind it:

  • If a reviewer says the game has a huge map, ask yourself whether you like exploration.
  • If they praise its difficult combat, ask whether you enjoy challenging games.
  • If they complain about repetitive missions, consider whether repetition bothers you.

The written details often tell you more than the number attached to the review.

Don't Judge a Game Entirely From Its Trailer

Trailers are designed to show a game's most appealing moments. That's their job.

But a two-minute trailer can't tell you everything about what it feels like to play a game for ten hours. Before buying, look for actual gameplay footage when possible. Watch someone play rather than watching only cinematic trailers.

Pay attention to:

  • How fast the gameplay moves
  • How complicated the controls appear
  • How much exploration is involved
  • Whether combat looks repetitive
  • How much dialogue there is
  • What a normal five-minute gameplay segment looks like

You're trying to imagine yourself playing it, not just watching someone else enjoy it.

Be Careful With the "Everyone Is Playing It" Trap

Popular games can be excellent, but popularity shouldn't automatically determine your choice.

Sometimes a game becomes popular because it fits a particular type of player extremely well. If you don't enjoy that type of experience, its popularity doesn't change much for you.

The right question isn't: "Why does everyone love this?"

It's: "Do the reasons they love it match the reasons I enjoy gaming?" That's a much better filter.

Try Before You Commit When You Can

Whenever there's a legitimate way to try a game before buying it, take advantage of that opportunity. Demos, free trials, free versions, and trial subscriptions can help you understand whether the basic gameplay appeals to you.

Sometimes 20 minutes of actual gameplay tells you more than an hour of reviews. Pay attention to your reaction:

  • Are you curious about what happens next?
  • Are you enjoying the controls?
  • Do you want to learn more?
  • Or are you already thinking about playing something else?

That initial reaction is invaluable information.

Don't Confuse a Game Being Good With It Being Right for You

This might be the most important idea in the entire guide: a game can be well-designed and still not be your game.

You don't need to justify that. Maybe you don't like horror. Maybe you don't enjoy open-world games. Maybe complicated crafting systems drive you crazy. Maybe competitive multiplayer makes you nervous. Maybe you simply don't have the patience for a 100-hour adventure.

That's fine. Gaming is personal. You don't need to force yourself through a highly praised game just because everyone says you should. Sometimes the right game is the one that makes you want to pick up the controller again tomorrow.

A Simple Method for Choosing Your Next Game

When you don't know what to play, use this 7-step process:

1. Identify your mood: Ask yourself what you want right now (relaxation, competition, story, strategy, exploration, creativity).

2. Choose two or three genres: Narrow the field rather than searching through every possible game.

3. Think about your available time: Do you have 30 minutes, two hours, or an entire weekend?

4. Find games that match those preferences: Look at recommendations, reviews, gameplay videos, and games similar to ones you already enjoy.

5. Remove the obvious mismatches: Eliminate games with deal-breakers like heavy competitive matchmaking or massive unskippable cutscenes.

6. Watch actual gameplay: Spend 5 minutes watching unedited gameplay footage.

7. Pick one: At some point, you have enough information. Choose a game and give it a fair chance.

What Video Game Should I Play Next?

If you're staring at your library asking, "What video game should I play next?", don't immediately start searching for another list of the year's best games. Start with yourself.

Ask: "What do I want from gaming tonight?"

  • If you want to relax, look for something comfortable and low-pressure.
  • If you want to challenge yourself, choose something that demands more concentration.
  • If you want to socialize, look for a multiplayer experience.
  • If you're curious about a story, choose something narrative-driven.
  • If you're bored with everything you've been playing, try something outside your normal genre.

That last option can be surprisingly effective. You don't necessarily need a better version of the same game; sometimes you need something completely different.

Finding a Game You'll Actually Enjoy

The best way to find new video games isn't to chase every popular release or blindly follow review scores. It's to understand your own gaming preferences:

  • "I want something strategic, but not too stressful."
  • "I want a story-driven game I can finish without spending 100 hours."
  • "I want multiplayer, but I don't want something extremely competitive."
  • "I want something I can play for 30 minutes at a time."

Those are useful descriptions, and they're much more likely to lead you toward a game you'll genuinely enjoy.

The next game doesn't have to be the biggest game. Think about the experience you want, narrow your options, look at real gameplay, and trust your own preferences. A game doesn't need to be universally loved to be worth your time; it just needs to give you a reason to keep playing.

Recommended Reading: Evaluating Time & Money Value

Now that you know how to zero in on the kind of experience you want, find out how to evaluate whether a game truly justifies its price tag: How to Know If a Video Game Is Worth Your Time and Money.

Learn practical ways to weigh game length against replayability, identify monetization red flags, and navigate seasonal sales with confidence.

About the Author — Elena Rostova

Elena Rostova is the Founder and Lead Technical Analyst of Game Vault Forum. Focused on PC hardware architecture, frame time pacing, and tactical game mechanics, his work emphasizes zero-hype, verifiable testing and consumer advocacy.